Loading...

Hickory Hill Brick Oven Pizza and Market

open now

  • Menu
  • About
  • Orders
  • Log In
  • Cart$0.00
Whoops, it looks like you've disabled browser cookies, please activate cookies to proceed with checkout.

Menu

Whoops, it looks like you've disabled browser cookies, please activate cookies to proceed with checkout.

  • Build your own Ice Cream!

    $2.75

    All Cones will be served on the side. Choose flavor, size!

  • Personal Pizza

    $9.00

    Build your own. 2 Toppings included and 16 oz drink

  • Build your own Sandwich

    $6.60

    Choose Meat & Cheese

  • Battered Haddock Sandwich

    $10.80

    Battered haddock fillet on a kaiser roll with fries. Tartar sauce for dipping

  • Build your own Sandwich

    $6.60

    Choose Meat & Cheese

  • Cheeseburger

    $13.19

    with lettuce, tomato and fries

  • Crispy Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

    $10.79

    Served on a kaiser roll with bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo with fries

  • French Dip

    $14.39

    Roast beef with sauteed onions, melted provolone cheese on a garlic sub roll with a side of au jus for dipping

  • Golden Fried Chicken

    $10.80

    4 pieces

  • Grilled chicken Caesar wrap

    $10.78

    with fries.

  • Ham and Swiss Sandiwch

    $8.10

    On marbled rye with lettuce, tomatoes, extra pickles and deli mustard

  • Jalapeno Mac & Cheese Square

    $4.80

    Breaded and deep fried

  • Meatball Parmigiana Hero

    $12.00

  • Roasted Veggie Wrap

    $11.98

    Roasted zucchini, yellow squash, red onions, cherry tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, lettuce & balsamic vinaigrette on a spinach wrap with fries

  • Sausage, Onion and Pepper Sub

    $12.00

  • Seafood Basket

    $1.60

    Battered haddock filets and shrimp with fries. Tartar sauce for dipping

  • Taco Seasoned Haddock Wrap

    $10.80

    Taco seasoned fried Haddock filets, our own salsa, lettuce, fresh guacamole in a flour tortilla with fries

  • 14" Pie - Build Your Own

    $14.40

    Choose Toppings

  • Personal Pizza

    $9.00

    Build your own. 2 Toppings included and 16 oz drink

  • 4 Seasons

    $10.20

    eggplant, mushroom, black olive, spinach

  • Margherita Pizza

    $9.00

    fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil & garlic

  • Meatlover

    $10.20

    pepperoni, meatball, bacon, & sausage

  • Supreme

    $11.50

    pepperoni, meatball, sausage, green pepper & onion

  • Vegan

    $9.00

    no cheese, spinach, broccoli, roasted pepper & garlic

  • Veggie

    $10.20

    tomato, broccoli, green pepper & spinach

  • American Cheese

    $3.60

    Boar's Head

  • Black Forest Ham

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Blazzing Buffalo Chicken

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Bologna

    $4.80

    Boar's Head

  • Cappy Ham

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Corned Beef

    $7.20

    Boar's Head

  • Cracked Peppermill Turkey

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Deluxe Ham - Half Pound

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • EverRoast Chicken

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Fresh Mozzarella

    $3.70

    Boar's Head

  • Genoa Salami

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Hard Salami

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Honey Maple Ham

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Honey Maple Turkey

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Liverworst

    $4.80

    Boar's Head

  • Monterey Jack w/ Jalepeno

    $4.80

    Boar's Head

  • Muenster

    $4.80

    Boar's Head

  • OvenGold Turkey

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Pastrami

    $7.20

    Boar's Head

  • Pepperoni

    $4.90

    Boar's Head

  • Prosciutto Di Parma

    $12.00

    Boar's Head

  • Provolone

    $3.60

    Boar's Head

  • Seasoned Roast Beef

    $8.40

    Boar's Head

  • Smoked Gouda

    $6.00

    Boar's Head

  • Sweet Sopressata

    $8.40

    Boar's Head

  • Swiss

    $6.00

    Boar's Head

  • Vermont Cheddar - Yellow

    $4.80

    Boar's Head

  • Vermont Cheddar- White

    $4.80

    Boar's Head

  • Virginia Ham

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Wisconsin Cheddar

    $6.80

    Boar's Head

  • Baked Macoroni & Cheese

    $14.40

    w/ side salad and garlic bread- put dressing type in special instructions

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    $20.40

    w/ side salad and garlic bread- put dressing type in special instructions

  • Chicken Tenders

    $12.00

    w/ french fries

  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    $19.20

    w/ side salad and garlic bread- put dressing type in special instructions

  • Spaghetti & Meatballs

    $15.60

    w/ side salad and garlic bread- put dressing type in special instructions

  • Build your own Ice Cream!

    $2.75

    All Cones will be served on the side. Choose flavor, size!

  • Milk Shake

    $5.40

    Choose Flavor and Size

  • Wise Chips

    $2.40

    choose your flavor

  • 20 oz Drink

    $2.40

    choose flavor

  • Bottled Water

    $2.40

    Choose Type

  • Coffee

    $2.40

    put sugar and milk choices in special instructions

  • Gatorade

    $3.15

    choose flavor

  • Red Bull

    $2.60

    Choose Type

Order

About Hickory Hill Brick Oven Pizza and Market


Hours

pre-order only

  1. Mon: 10:00am – 8:00pm
  2. Tue: 10:00am – 8:00pm
  3. Wed: 10:00am – 8:00pm
  4. Thu: 10:00am – 8:00pm
  5. Fri: 10:00am – 8:00pm
  6. Sat: 10:00am – 8:00pm
  7. Sun: 10:00am – 8:00pm

5200 NY-23
Windham, NY 12496

(518) 734-6300

Delivery Minimum $15.00
Map of Hickory Hill Brick Oven Pizza and Market

Powered by Ontray

© 2026 All rights reserved

  • Sign In
  • Register

forgot?

No account? Register for Free

  • Log in with Facebook
Register with Facebook

By clicking Create Account, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Reset your password

Enter the email address associated with your account below, and you will receive an email with instructions to reset your password.

Back to Login

Ontray logo

Ontray provides online ordering for local restaurants.

Find your Address

Loading...Use LocationUse Location
Search by Address

Change Delivery Time

Cart Errors

    Search Address

    Use Location Use Location Clear Location

    Reorder Meal?

    Note: you will be able to review your order before checking out.

    Confirm Reorder

    The items in your previous order have changed. Review the changes and click 'Continue' below, you will be able to review your cart before checking out.